Cheater, Cheater, Ice Cream Eater :-)

Need a quick “cheat” for “homemade ice cream”?  I learned the most clever idea last night.  At a church fellowship, both Patsy and Billy (2 separate households) brought “made at home” Butterfinger ice cream.  When I commented about them looking just alike, they both laughed and shared this fabulous secret.  I snapped a picture so I could pass it along to you.

Homemade Butterfinger Ice cream 
(Keep in mind: Homemade = made at home.  Right?)

1 galon of good vanilla ice cream
24 snack size or 8 regular size Butterfinger candy bars

Here’s the “Home-made” part: Let the ice cream soften a little.  Crush the candy bars.  Billy used a blender.  Patsy used a meat tenderizer.  Doesn’t matter how – just crush ’em.  Then mix them into the ice cream and refreeze.  Voila! Home prepared, made, created, however you want to say it, ice cream.  Easy and delicious!

If you want it to look extra homemade, you can even transfer it to an ice cream freezer canister. (grin)  If anyone asks you if you made your ice cream yourself, you can honestly say yes. 😉

My mind is swirling with ideas for this.  Basically any type of candy or cookie would work, as well as caramel or chocolate drizzle stirred in.  Oreos, snickers, chocolate chip cookies, Heath Bars, M & M’s, Reeces Pieces, Peppermint Patties… Anything Dairy Queen can put in a blizzard, you can put into a gallon of vanilla ice cream.  I can’t wait to make this myself!

Thanks Patsy and Billy!  From now on, for occasions when I don’t have time to make home-churned ice cream, I’ll definitely become a “Cheater, Cheater, Ice-Cream Eater!”  Thanks for letting me pass it along~


About SmellingCoffee

I'm a Jesus-loving, husband-loving, family-loving minister's wife and mom to two college kids, making our home and serving our Lord in the Mississippi Delta. I study, teach, speak, and write for the greatest Boss in the universe. "Faith, Family, Food, Fun, and Living Life brewed in the fragrance of the knowledge of Jesus Christ in every place": That's what you'll find at


  1. Great idea…does remind you alot of the Blizzard – should serve it in cups with big spoon/straws:)

  2. Kim {Recipes To Run On} says:

    Okay, this is amazing! I would never have thought you could re~freeze the icecream. But, now I can't wait to try. And I'm with you…. the possibilities are endless. It could be fun in the fall with fall flavors, peppermint flavors at Christmas. YUM!

  3. How cool! (Literally) And what fun for a fellowship. Yep, this one's a keeper.